Is American Horsemeat Safe to Eat?

When people start talking about how horsemeat is just like beef or pork and why shouldn’t they eat it, etc etc, I always say, sure! go ahead! but do you know the source of the horseflesh you’re eating?

If you can guarantee that the horse you’re making into steak was (a) raised wild or (b) raised purely for meat, then you’re safe as houses. If, however, that horse has been used for riding or sports then, well, you might as well ingest BSE-riddled beef or salmonella-laden eggs. The veterinary drugs that those horses have been given are not safe for secondhand human consumption, and you’ll find plenty of peer-reviewed scientific material to back that up.

The EU is now introducing regulations to try to safeguard European consumers of horsemeat from these dangerous trace substances, but as a fair amount of the horseflesh consumed comes from the USA and Canada, there’s been a lot of speculation as to how well this will be policed.

Racehorses (in the US A LOT of drugs go into these animals in particular) are going directly from the track to slaughter. Some of the firms which are doing the slaughtering in Canada and Mexico have pretty poor histories of following safety procedures.

The Equine Welfare Alliance (more here) Lucille Matte has launched a new site aiming to provide information to European consumers, by anti-slaughter advocates, called American Horsemeat. I have some issues with the content – it’s not true that horsemeat is a delicacy here in Europe (it’s often cheap supermarket meat) – but they do seem to have tried to give links to peer-reviewed papers rather than being excessively emotive.

It’ll be interesting to see what happens as the legislation supposedly swings into effect.

3 thoughts on “Is American Horsemeat Safe to Eat?

  1. EWA did not launch americanhorsmeat.com I did personally. My goal is to get the attention of the people in Europe that eat horse meat from North and South American.

    I appreciate any input you might have.

  2. Thank you Lucille! I will update accordingly.
    I have to say that the only horse meat I’ve seen for sale in Berlin was cheap, supermarket sausage, so it’s not really a delicacy here, nor much consumed at all in Northern Germany.
    I know a lot of horse people in the UK are highly sceptical about the passport and chip system (passports can be officially dished out by dodgy markets, and chips removed from horses’ necks). It’s definitely a consumer information issue – they will put pressure on authorities to make sure the business is conducted according to EU regulations when they have the kind of information that’s on your site.

  3. Pingback: Horses, Medication and Meat: A Digest of the Indigestible « If Wishes Were Horses

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s